In September, the City Council held a hearing on the proposed appointment of John Mangin to be the Chair of the Board of Standards and Appeals (BSA). The BSA is a quasi-judicial agency that makes decisions on zoning that are outside of the usual processes. Now let’s be clear: the City of Yes and the Charter Ballot questions that were approved have already made it much easier for developers to do what they want as-of-right or with little oversight from the City Council, reversing decades of input and relevance of your elected officials and neighborhoods across the city (including your own). John Mangin, the previous head of the Department of City Planning’s Housing Division, is the primary architect of the City of Yes for Housing Opportunity (COYHO) which we fought so hard against. He also authored the Land Use Charter Ballot questions from last year that were adopted which have taken away an enormous amount of power from the City Council on land use decisions – and we are currently in litigation, as discussed previously. That alone should be disqualifying; however, he also has a long history of being unbelievably hostile to homeowners, single-family houses and other key indicators of the “American Dream” that most people in the United States aspire to achieve. In a key paper that he wrote in 2014 for Stanford Law and Policy Review, he describes homeowners as having “cartel-like interests” when it comes to wanting to protect their communities; community benefits agreements – which often work to balance new development with promises from the developer to include things that communities want or need in exchange for an approval – get in the way of development; is opposed to many forms of rent control; and does not support affordable housing “to the exclusion of other types of development” which is key to his design of COYHO, which literally has no affordability included in it whatsoever – just more luxury and market-rate housing destroying our neighborhoods. In 2019, he wrote an article for the Yale Law Review entitled “Ethnic Enclaves and the Zoning Game” in which he laid out – in great detail – his plan to destroy zoning protections throughout the city, particularly in low-density neighborhoods. His contempt for both neighborhood stability and character and his overwhelming hostility in clear racial terminology is more than disturbing: it reveals his agenda outright. Mangin is also a serial liar. I have had personal experience in watching and going head-to-head with him. At the hearing for COYHO in 2024 at Community Board 11 in Queens, Mangin presented the proposal in front of hundreds of concerned residents who asked many pointed questions. His responses were lies: for example, his answer on transit-oriented development (TODs) which radically increases density as-of-right under City of Yes if the area is located in the Greater Transit Zone (of which enormous swathes of the outer boroughs are now located) was that “so few properties would be affected that no one will even notice it.” This was a bald-faced lie, and this was BEFORE COYHO was amended to carve out R1 and R2 zones from TODs. Had that not happened, the additional development potential would have been staggering. All of Mangin’s many lies were recorded at that meeting. In our lawsuit, he was the key witness for the City’s position to defend the City of Yes. His response, under oath, is also riddled with lies. At the hearing last month, he again lied constantly and consistently to the often-hostile questions from Councilmembers who claimed that they were concerned about Mangin running the BSA, an agency that they have no oversight over their basic decision making and cannot overturn once a determination has been made. The City Council voted for him overwhelmingly anyway a week later after he had “private” conversations with several key members that “allayed concerns,” including Speaker Julie Menin. This is an unelected position wholly controlled by the Mayor once the Council confirms the candidate – and they did just that. |
SAVE1FNYArchives
November 2026
Categories |

RSS Feed